Marcel Tabuteau First-Hand

MT era oboe

Laila Storch’s Oboe Lessons 1946-47

Laila’s Private Lessons with Tabuteau 1946-47
Ludlow Building Studio

At this point, Laila was engaged to play English horn in the Kansas City Philharmonic Orchestra. So, she took four private lessons with Tabuteau as preparation.

Lesson 1: September 9, 1946

Don’t play so sharp. You have too much of your lips on the teeth. Pull your lower jaw back further with more lower lip for a rounder tone. Play on O. Don’t play so tight and shrill. Play with more continuity of line by using the wind. Practice on a smaller scale, not so big.

Wagner Lohengrin:

Laila's notes 2-13
Diagram 13

Narrow your gauge between the notes.

Lesson 2: September 12, 1946

Sellner Duos [not specified]

Play away or closer to the bridge. A real line comes about because the notes on the wind are part of one another; don’t make a break. Play with your teeth in a natural position, your upper over your lower. Your lower lip must be like a flexible spring or cushion: in and out all the time. Don’t try to take the music; let it take you.

Lesson 3: September 13, 1946: Reed-Making Information

Do not scrape back too far at first, and make the tip quite thin:

Laila's notes 2-14
Diagram 14

Then take definite scrapes or cuts from the back. The reed must have a bridge.

Light scrapes here can sharpen the pitch:

Laila's notes 2-15
Diagram 15

Oboe measurements: [Tabuteau’s dictation: Laila is ordering a new Loree: Tabuteau System to replace her open-hole Loree]

Laila's notes 2-16
Diagram 16

Tubes [staples]: 47 mm.

Gouging machine and shaper specifications [Tabuteau’s dictation to Laila for having Ernst Graf in Philadelphia make Laila a gouging machine and a shaper]:

Laila's notes 2-17
Diagram 17
Laila's notes 2-18
Diagram 18

Damn Fool! Make the reed play fairly easily on the front [tip & heart] before scraping too far back. Make the tip thin, so it plays in pitch on the oboe. It must play the pitch without pinching (the secret of a reed).

To sharpen reed knives: bring the stone toward and against the blade, not in the same direction.

To test reeds in the high register: use the low B to play the harmonic F♯, then to regular F♯ and highest E followed by Fork F.

To test reeds in the low register play low C to F♯, then down to C♯ and up to E.

Make reed so you can play on the tip and not have the F♯ and G sink or play wild. They must be sure with a solid fundamental. Make it so you can play on the wind. The wind does everything.

Tabuteau’s staples 53 mm by my measuring. [Unlikely, as earlier Laila wrote .47 mm.]

The ideal gouge [appears to be .60 mm in the center and .505 mm on the sides]:

Laila's notes 2-19
Diagram 19

However, the distribution of some measurements can be different, i.e. less taper to .50 mm at the edges resulting in more belly and ribs.

Reeds: for darkness, scrape the surface (bark) only very lightly.

Laila's notes 2-20
Diagram 20

Scrape the edge here without the plaque to take out vibration and dull the reed:

Laila's notes 2-21
Diagram 21

Or take out vibration here:

Laila's notes 2-22
Diagram 22

Or take out vibration here:

Laila's notes 2-23
Diagram 23

Don’t dig out the middle of the reed, instead scrape on the side channels. The reed has to play in tune on the oboe at piano and without lip pressure, but it must be able to take the wind pressure and not sink.

Several high-note fingerings:

Laila's notes 2-23
Diagram 24

Lesson 4: September 19, 1946

Practice all of the Ferling Studies on English horn.

Hold your arms forward. The pressure of the left hand changes qualities of sound: do a lot with it, darken your tone.

Franck D Minor Symphony [most likely the English horn part]: Sing more!

Beethoven Symphony 5: 1st movement solo: Turn each note: fa-mi-re / 4-3-1 / down-up-down. Practice the circle, and don’t play pinched. Give more, play full. There is an emotional element in this solo; it is not shallow.

Practice broken 10ths both slurred and detached. Play piano, a forte is a small tone made large, Drive and lift the embouchure.

Re-fa’-la-la’ = D F’ A A’

You have enough technique to do everything well. But you must practice well and get the correct embouchure. Play all the notes in-between the intervals. As long as you realize how bad you are, then there is hope, and you will improve.

Mendelssohn Midsummer Night’s Dream, Scherzo

Beethoven Symphony 6, 3rd Movement Scherzo

Wagner Siegfried, Forest Murmurs

Laila is now back in Philly from Kansas City Season 1946-47.
She takes a single lesson. Laila will play another season in Kansas City 1947-48.

May 1947

Work on solo repertoire: Paladilhe, Handel, Mozart, and Lefebre.

George Gillet Studies [not specified]

Be prepared, now you must not let down. But since you have begun to understand a little, this is the time to work. Sometimes it is a little thing that can make for a decision.

In orchestra, don’t try to put a finish on at first. That is backwards and then you will miss. You must first play (not like in lessons) and then what you have learned should show through a little. Polish later. First, you must sound.

Sections

Much of the material on this website is being presented with kind permission of the copyright owners. Any use and/or duplication of certain materials must be approved by the copyright owners. Therefore, you must seek permission at msmostovoy@comcast.net before using or duplicating any material to ascertain whether it is presently under copyright. Certain excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given as per the instructions you will receive from your inquiry. If this website has inadvertently posted material without the proper attribution or authorization, to remedy, please contact msmostovoy@comcast.net.

What's New!

An audio interview with Joan Browne (Champie), a private Tabuteau student in the early 1950s.

A photograph of the music stand that was in Tabuteau’s private studio in Philadelphia.

An autographed photo of Marcel Tabuteau inscribed to Vladimir Sokoloff.

An autographed photo of Marcel Tabuteau inscribed to Joan Browne Champie.

With the passing of Wilbur Isaac Hilles in August 2023 and now Martha Scherer-Alfee in February 2024, no oboe students of Marcel Tabuteau at the Curtis Institute are still living.

A letter sent to the Curtis Institute by Laila Storch’s mother about Tabuteau not teaching at Curtis—and the reply.